By GottaLaff
Livebloggin MSNBC:
Rachel Maddow: This was an anti-oratorical speech... prose. We're used to poetry when it comes to war, the military. No bumper stickers. Pragmatic, down to earth, not soaring rhetoric. A practical approach.
Chris Matthews: There's no clear cut enemy. An indirect war. Don't think he made the point of what we can do relative to what we can't do.
Rachel: One major problem... can't make a coherent case of why were not just leaving. He fudged Pakistan and Afghanistan together. We have a war fought by CIA in Pakistan, by military in Afghanistan.
Chris: Many are against this war. The Cheney rights will hate him, the independents are war weary, left is against the war. So he could be alone.
Rachel: I disagree. He neutralized the opposition... helped left by promise of ending. And right by sending in troops.
Chris: He'll be called the reluctant warrior by the Cheney types... ditherer.... Not a lot of warmth in crowd, especially in older viewers. A strange venue.
Rachel: We're used to Bush jingoistic speeches. He liked the adulation. Obama talking about balancing military with other needs of nation is maybe the most adult thing told to American audiences on the military issue.
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
Post-Afghanistan speech commentary
Labels:
afghan war,
commentary,
msnbc,
President Obama,
presidential speeches,
speeches
blog comments powered by Disqus