Showing posts with label pragmatist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pragmatist. Show all posts

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Obama puts pragmatism over promises

By GottaLaff


If you didn't already know that President Obama tends to be more of a centrist than a liberal, or if you didn't expect it, then you most likely haven't been paying attention. I'm surprised at the surprise of so many who believed that President Obama was a die-hard lefty. He never presented himself that way, as I've said in previous posts, and he has always maintained that he'd try to meet the other side halfway. That doesn't sound all that ultra-lib to me.

This article in the L.A. Times discusses his "flip flops":
Unlike his predecessor, George W. Bush, who styled himself as "the Decider" and took pride in sticking with decisions come what might, Obama is emerging as a leader so committed to pragmatism that he will move to a new position with barely a shrug.

Whether it's a long-standing campaign promise or a recent Oval Office decision, Obama has shown a willingness to reverse himself and even anger his most liberal supporters if he can advance a higher-priority goal or avoid what he sees as a distracting controversy.
William A. Galston, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and former advisor to President Clinton:
"If he's basically faithful to the agenda he ran on, the reversals -- such as they are -- are going to be seen as tolerable exceptions rather than as leading indicators," he said. "If you are a single-issue person, what the president says in regard to your issue may be a bitter disappointment."
Now about those 180s:
The recent shifts appear to be part of a pattern of starting in a liberal position and then rerouting toward the center.
Surprise! (Only if you hadn't been paying attention for the past two years)
Though for the most part liberals have held their fire, the last week's events raise the question of how long they will tolerate the pattern. [...]

As the House debated war funding last week, House Appropriations Committee Chairman David R. Obey (D-Wis.) compared his position to when, after being elected to the House as an antiwar candidate in 1969, he initially gave President Nixon's war policy the benefit of the doubt.

"I decided to give him a year. I'm pretty much in the same position," Obey said. "We have no choice but to give the president a shot. It's a miserable situation that he's inherited, and he does not have a good hand to play."
For those of us who are disappointed in some of his decisions, keep in mind that the alternative would have been much worse. Obama won the nomination. It was down to him or ::shudder:: McCain/Palin. He is light years better, smarter, wiser, and way leftier than they ever would have been.

When we disagree strongly enough with his positions, then we should make sure we are heard. Call or write your representatives, notify the White House web site, email letters to the editors of your local newspapers. But while whining and stomping our collective feet is a great release, it won't move those proverbial mountains. Only being pro-active will.

And if there is one thing we have learned, it's that President Obama is a very good listener.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Obama the pragmatic idealist

By GottaLaff

The L.A. Times' Doyle McManus analyzes President Obama's first few days in office, and concludes that he is "both idealistic and competent, which was nice for the country but a potential disaster for the satire industry." He also reminds us that he's not a saint. (I doubt anyone here at TPC thinks he is.) The righties love to push that line on the Tee Vee Machine, and we get more of that in this opinion piece:

At least he was being honest [re: "I screwed up."]. Obama's decision to accept Daschle's withdrawal wasn't the product of a sudden ethical insight; it was a ruthlessly practical political judgment. And that is characteristic of this idealistic president who, in a crunch, turns out to be -- like all successful politicians -- a pragmatist. [...]

Obama fans haven't cared to notice, but pragmatism has been the guiding nonprinciple in plenty of the president's decisions. Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner had tax problems too, but Obama correctly calculated that he would skate into office because his mission was too important to let a few tax issues get in the way.
Um, we actually have noticed. Give us a little credit for having eyes and ears. But let's let that one slide. Moving on:
None of this is surprising, nor is it necessarily bad. Some Obama supporters cling to their view of him as a saint. They need to get over that.
There it is again. Enough with the "you think he's the Messiah" line. We don't. Why doesn't McManus get over that? We simply find ourselves releasing all that pent up anger and disgust after 8 years of the president from hell. It's more about expressing our hope and expectations of a highly competent leader who is the anti-Bush. It's called relief, not idolatry.
Successful Democratic presidents have always sought a balance of idealism and practicality, and have always been criticized by their left wing for straying from perfection. Franklin D. Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson and Bill Clinton all proclaimed lofty goals and then cut deals. But in Obama's case, the goals were very, very lofty -- and the promise to change the way Washington works was always going to be the most difficult to keep. Last week, he gave up his remaining claim to sainthood [!!!] but preserved his chance to be a successful president.

That chance now rests on his economic plan, and Obama was right to put that before everything else. Two years from now, voters will know firsthand whether the stimulus worked; they are less likely to remember why Daschle didn't get a Cabinet seat. [...]

The question now is how many of his beloved long-term investments in energy, education and healthcare will Obama abandon to get a big stimulus bill passed? If his record is any guide, he'll give up whatever he must to protect the things he cares most about. [...]

"Those who accomplish the most are those who don't make the perfect the enemy of the good," Tom Daschle said then. "Barack is a pragmatist."
Some interesting points were made, but it would have been nice if McManus had dropped the Tee Vee Machine talking points. At this rate, if he's not careful, he may never achieve sainthood.

Monday, January 12, 2009

ObamAgenda

By GottaLaff

Commenter Ady said this in another thread:

"Obama is extremely pragmatic. He'll always be wiling to give a little to accomplish his long term goals."
Commenter Nellcote then linked to a substantial piece about Obama and his environmental policies that ended with this:
“Obama is not defining his agenda with any particular focus on what the environmental community would want him to do,” [Dan Esty, a Yale professor and environmental economist who was a founding member of Obama’s advisory committee] says. “It’s a uniquely Obama vision of how to go forward - it’ll be attractive across a broad public spectrum, but it won’t be universally acclaimed by the environmental community.” Still, those who’ve known Obama longest remain hopeful that he’ll be able to navigate the challenges that lie ahead. “Community organizers are pragmatists,” says Galluzzo, the South Side organizer who once trained Obama. “It’s not about being an idealist, it’s about moving the agenda forward. You learn politics as the art of the possible.” In the choices Obama has made as he’s progressed from the South Side to Springfield to Washington, Galluzzo sees the same tensions confronted by every grassroots activist: idealism marbled with pragmatism, a readiness to compromise to get things done, a willingness to settle for incremental change. “When Barack Obama becomes president we’ll have an environmental president,” he says. “But will he be a purist on every environmental issue? The answer is no.” Ultimately, Galluzzo says, Obama’s environmentalism is predicated upon an unwillingness to allow the perfect to become the enemy of the good. The question is whether that will be good enough.
This, to me, sums things up perfectly, and not just about Obama's enviromental policies. The expectations of his presidency are so high right now, he couldn't possibly live up to them. But he does seem to know how to take steps in the right direction, accomplish a few things, and vastly improve on what we've had up until now.

Recent Posts