By GottaLaff
So much for what IWRC* Palin brings to the energy table:
In an early exchange with Sen. Joseph Biden during the vice presidential debate in St. Louis on Thursday, Palin called energy her “area of expertise.” She talked about her deep energy experience throughout the evening. [...]
A close examination of Palin’s energy background, however, reveals that the GOP vice presidential candidate has only a relatively short history of studying and working on this issue. Palin served as chairwoman of a state energy board, a position reserved for a private citizen, for 11 months. A year before running for governor, Palin joined a group of other Republicans in TV ads advocating an all-Alaska gas pipeline route, though she eventually didn’t support this in office. As governor, Palin made a series of distinctly populist energy decisions that yielded short-term political gains, rather than policies designed for the long-term benefit of Alaska.
In a more than a dozen interviews over the course of a month with Alaska insiders and close observers of state politics, most say Palin does not have a deep understanding of energy policy as she has claimed on the presidential campaign trail. In fact, she’s regularly described, even by those who support her policies, as having little expertise in the area.
There are a number of specific criticisms. Palin’s been accused of taking credit for the work of her predecessor, Gov. Frank Murkowski, in pushing through oil tax policy changes; promoting policies that may not actually further her pro-drilling mantra; hiring a personal friend and college drop-out to head a $40-billion oil revenue fund; calling the gas pipeline project a success, though it may never be built, and ignoring the root causes of the state’s consumer energy problems.
On the campaign trail, Palin has frequently touted her experience in standing up to big oil by supporting a windfall profit tax as an example of her energy experience. Though Palin now praises the plan, which has filled the state’s coffers with billions in additional revenues, she opposed the measure when running for office in 2006.
Oliver Scott Goldsmith, economics professor and director of the Institute of Social and Economic Research at the University of Alaska, Anchorage:
“I see her as the person who’s taken a hard stance with the [oil] industry — when it’s been politically attractive to do that.”
The article goes into some detail. Here are more excerpts:
Now that Palin is running for national office, it’s difficult to imagine how her rebate policy would play out across the country. Palin made the energy program successful in her state because the relationship between oil and the economy is so closely tied, unlike the rest of the country or even any other state or region. “It’s not the sort of thing you can make work on the national level,” said Cliff Groh, an Anchorage attorney who oversaw taxes for the state in the 1990s. “Alaska is so different it’s hard to extrapolate to the other 49 states. I don’t think there’s quite that much money.”
Even Palin’s explicit national policy – or mantra – “drill baby, drill,” is contentious.
During the vice presidential debate, Palin insisted that her experience in Alaska can help the United States move toward energy independence.
Palin implied that her most successful drilling project is well underway in Alaska. “And we’re building a nearly $40 billion natural gas pipeline,” Palin said, “which is North America’s largest and most expensive infrastructure project ever to flow those sources of energy into hungry markets.”
The only problem is: the project is at least a decade away from completion. [...]
An even bigger problem for the project is that no clients have signed on to use the pipeline. In fact, the three largest oil producers in the state, BP, Conocco Phillips and Exxon Mobil, have already said they will not use the pipeline and would prefer to invest in their own.
Dan Dickinson, a consultant to the state legislature on energy:
“Can I think of anything she did to increase energy independence?” Dickinson asked himself. “No.”
Deconstructing IWRC Sarah.
*"In What Respect, Charlie?"